*This rating is granted to Stillwater Insurance Company and Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company.

Download the stillwater mobile app today View and share policy information and documents, make payments and view billing history, and quickly submit claims as they happen.

Claims Report a Claim: 24 hours a day / 7 days a week (800) 220-1351 [email protected]

The Stillwater Insurance Group is made up of three separate companies: Stillwater Insurance Company; Stillwater Insurance Services, Inc; and Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company.

FIND AN AGENT To find a Stillwater agent near you enter your zip code and click submit.

Stillwater InsuranceSign in

Access your Stillwater Insurance account online to manage policies, view payment history, and update account settings conveniently.

Once we've reviewed your information, we'll be in touch to discuss whether a partnership with Stillwater is the right fit. Check out Stillwater product availability by state.

Jack, NY, December 03, 2025 Gianni was very professional, helpful and friendly. It was great doing business with him and Stillwater. My car looks great. Thank you. Sankaralingam, NJ, November 13, …

Personalize your coverage* to match your needs With Stillwater, you can build a policy that'll help you stay financially whole if the unthinkable happens. Your policy's main coverages: Dwelling - Pays to …